# Claims sheet — Community S6E3 "Basic Crisis Room Decorum" (v3 review)

Every concrete episode fact used in the review, each with a verbatim source line. Gate F1/F2 in hv_review_gate_v2.py verifies each EVIDENCE line appears verbatim (case/whitespace-normalized) in a SOURCE file.

ATTRIBUTION-NOTE: the Springfield transcript carries no speaker labels. All who-does-what attribution is taken from the fandom recap (SOURCE 2), never guessed off the label-less transcript.
ATTRIBUTION-NOTE: credits (director Bobcat Goldthwait, writer Monica Padrick) are from the Wikipedia Community season 6 episode table.

SOURCE: /Users/drwu/Projects/_outputs/horror-vanguard-reviewer/community/s6e3-transcript.txt

CLAIM: Annie is tipped off early that City College is running an ad against Greendale
EVIDENCE: City College is running a negative ad about your school

CLAIM: An emergency meeting of the committee is called
EVIDENCE: Need to call emergency meeting ASAP.

CLAIM: The attack ad frames Ruffles as a dog who lived on campus
EVIDENCE: a Staffordshire terrier named Ruffles took up residence on Greendale's campus

CLAIM: The ad's specific charge is that the dog earned a degree
EVIDENCE: By 2008, Ruffles had earned a bachelor's degree.

CLAIM: The committee cannot immediately say whether Greendale did it
EVIDENCE: Did we give a degree to a dog?

CLAIM: Jeff reframes the question from truth to provability
EVIDENCE: did a dog get a degree here in any way that can be proven?

CLAIM: Annie finds the dog's academic record in the files
EVIDENCE: It's a transcript for a dog.

CLAIM: Annie frames leaving as enrolling where her grades matter
EVIDENCE: enroll at the one where my grades matter?

CLAIM: The committee accepts Annie transferring as the price of the file
EVIDENCE: If the price of that transcript is you transferring we accept.

CLAIM: The mis-texted teenager is named Takashi
EVIDENCE: I am Takashi.

CLAIM: The wrong-number gag resolves with the teenager becoming a crime boss
EVIDENCE: the moment that would lead me to becoming oyabun, highest leader of the Yakuza.

SOURCE: /Users/drwu/Projects/_outputs/horror-vanguard-reviewer/community/s6e3-recap-fandom.txt

CLAIM: Britta arrives at the meeting drunk
EVIDENCE: inebriated Britta makes an appearance

CLAIM: Elroy returns Britta to the room in oversized borrowed trousers
EVIDENCE: now wearing oversized trousers she got from Elroy Patashnik

CLAIM: Frankie tells Annie that hoping the claim is false is pointless
EVIDENCE: wishful thinking is wasted action

CLAIM: The dog attended but never received a degree, making the ad false
EVIDENCE: there is no record of a degree being given to Ruffles

CLAIM: Chang's private counter-attack is a solo porno shot on City College's campus
EVIDENCE: by shooting a solo porno video on that campus

CLAIM: The committee's honest ad has the Dean confess the dog was a student
EVIDENCE: confessing that she was once a student at Greendale

CLAIM: The confession ad ends on Greendale needing to reform
EVIDENCE: school needs to get its act together

CLAIM: Annie reads the honest ad as the group taking the high road
EVIDENCE: would take the high road

CLAIM: Jeff frames the honest ad as the smart move, not the moral one
EVIDENCE: prudent course of action